The Oshawa Express - Hospital Foundation broke Rundle House promise
   
Hospital Foundation broke Rundle House promise


Dear Editor:

Once again, Alexandra Park lands and a significant heritage building, Rundle House, 364
Simcoe Street North, is at risk. Rundle House was purchased by the Oshawa Hospital Foundation in 1991. They were fully aware that it was a significant heritage building and they promised to be good caretakers. A few years later, The Durham Home Builders Association offered to renovate the interior of Rundle House free of charge so it could serve as the cancer lodge. The Hospital Foundation sent them away.

Years passed by and like a slum landlord, the OHF neglected Rundle House. They left it empty and allowed it to deteriorate. Now they are threatening to destroy it. If they demolish Rundle House, before obtaining the zoning they require, they will be putting donated dollars at risk. This would be irresponsible because the resale value is in the house and lot - together.

In 1994, there was a plan to put a road through Alexandra Park from Simcoe Street North opposite Aberdeen. This would have sectioned off the south treed area of the park.

This idea was abandoned when area residents strongly objected. Later, after an Ontario Municipal Board Hearing, the Ministry of Health refused to allow the hospital to build the cancer centre in Alexandra Park.

As a result, we now have a larger, more efficient cancer centre, which is located on hospital lands exactly where the hospital claimed it could not be built. Also, as a result of the 1996 OMB decision, an Oshawa Official Plan Amendment protects Alexandra Park from any future development or encroachment. Alexandra Park is irreplaceable green space.

It functions as both a neighbourhood and a community park. It is located in one of the oldest residential areas in Oshawa. If this green space were lost, it would be lost forever. Alexandra Park is the oldest public park in Oshawa. It also has heritage value. It is well used. For example, O'Neill (OCVI) students use the park for their recreational needs.

The Hospital Foundation is claiming they have been unable to acquire an alternative site for the cancer lodge. What they have not disclosed is that they refuse to pay fair market value for real estate close to the hospital and they refuse to consider renovating a building one block away that already has the zoning required for the cancer lodge.

It appears they only want to build new! This is their choice. It is a free marketplace. However, this does not warrant the destruction of Rundle House or giving away public parkland. This would be shortsighted.

Rundle House zoning is protected on the south lot line by a strip of land that is owned by the City of Oshawa. This strip of land was intentionally placed there by city council as a barrier to protect Rundle House and the properties running north on Simcoe Street from redevelopment/rezoning attempts.

Demolishing Rundle House will not change this fact. Everyone would like to see a cancer lodge up and operating as soon as possible, however, the Oshawa Hospital Foundation would be wise to reconsider their plans.

Options are available but they must be more flexible. Rundle House and Alexandra Park must not be sacrificed because the OHF is being unreasonable in their search for another site. It is time to stop destroying our heritage. Heritage buildings are part of the fabric of our communities.

 

Joy Wawrzyniak
Oshawa

 
     
       
     

 

| The Oshawa Express | Contact Us |
600 Thornton Rd. S., Oshawa, Ontario L1J 6W7
©2008 Dowellman Publishing Corp, All Rights Reserved